Traders Casa vs Edgewonk
Test the strategy, not just the trades
Traders Casa gives you chart-based replay backtesting alongside trade journalling and analytics. Start free forever, or get six years of historical data and fuller analytics for $8.95/month.
The honest verdict
Edgewonk is the stronger choice if trading psychology and behavioural discipline are your priority. Its Tiltmeter tracks how often you break your own rules and relates that behaviour to P&L and win rate, backed by tools including the Psychology Lab, mental journal and session report cards. Its $197-a-year plan also includes entry and exit optimisation, alternative strategy testing and unlimited journals, accounts and trades. It works across forex, stocks, futures, crypto and options. If you mainly want to understand how your decisions and discipline affect real trades, Edgewonk has a genuinely distinctive toolkit.
Traders Casa is the better fit if you want to generate test trades on historical charts rather than only analyse trades you have already taken. Its bar-by-bar replay lets you practise on TradingView-powered charts, rewind, jump to dates, use custom indicators and journal the resulting backtests. You can start free forever with unlimited backtest sessions and trades; Basic is $8.95/month, while Pro is $30/month with live mode, broker sync, 300+ analytics and Casa AI insights. Traders Casa does not offer tick-level data, automated strategy testing, stocks or futures.
Traders Casa vs Edgewonk at a glance
| Traders Casa | Edgewonk | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Free forever — unlimited backtest sessions | No free plan — 14-day money-back guarantee |
| Price | From $8.95/mo, or $7.16/mo billed annually | $197 a year, single plan, VAT added at checkout |
| Pricing model | Three tiers — pay for what you need | One plan, everything included, no tiers |
| Bar replay backtesting | Yes — bar-by-bar on TradingView-powered charts | Not offered — works on trades you have taken |
| Strategy testing | Test a strategy before you trade it | Alternative management rules on past trades |
| Trading psychology | Consistency tracker and trade journalling | Tiltmeter, Psychology Lab, session report cards |
| Trade journalling | Backtests on every plan, live trades on Pro | Unlimited journals, accounts and trades |
| Markets | Forex, indices, metals and crypto | Forex, stocks, futures, crypto and options |
| Platform | Web-based — nothing to install | Web-based |
Comparison based on each product's public pricing and feature pages. Spotted something out of date? Tell us and we'll fix it.
What Traders Casa users are saying
Guys Traders Casa is the best Backtesting platform on the web right now, not many people know about this, it's better than FX Replay. Very underrated. I just purchased the Ad Free version today...
@quasitrading
Been using this for over a months, it's really amazing software
@Abahrios
Thank you Traders Casa, without you my trading would not have improved. Thank you very much from Thailand. ❤️
@mAJOTRADER
🌟 I've been using @traders_casa for a few months now, and I have to say, their updates are insane! From new features to improved tools, they've really listened to our feedback and made meaningful changes.
@M4rky___
Man, if only I realised I could Backtest on mobile with @traders_casa 2 months ago🤩🤩.( I prefer trading on my phone).Backtesting is going to be the only game I play for a while🤣🤣already addicted
@Chihwa_fx
No way I have just found out about @traders_casa. You guys are absolute legends.
@Giorderflow
Yall deserve a 10 star if it was available
@Impulse__EU
For real yall should try out @traders_casa loving their free version and the paid version is even more amazing. The paid version gives you amazing analytics feature on your live account. It's superb. Mind you I have zero affiliation with these guys. I just live their work so much
@Impulse__EU
@traders_casa wowow! I just registered and in awe with your service!! Thank you so much 🥹
@Cubtradingfx
Having a statistical strategy with proof of it's max losing/winning streak probabilities will certainly build an effective risk management plan, set a reasonable expectations and even know if its seasonal or works for years. I got surprised @traders_casa provide free tool
@AkenyanTrader
How can I thank the creators and developers of traders casa personally?. They outdid themselves in creating this amazing project. I am forever grateful and thankful to them for making such available affordable options to millions of users. I can honestly say my trading improved a lot since I came across them. And it’s cost me way lesser than it would’ve on any other back testing sites. GRATITUDE 💪🏾
lollipop131513
Guys Traders Casa is the best Backtesting platform on the web right now, i honestly feel you guys have not done marketing well enough, not many people know about this, your platform is better than FX Replay. Very underrated. I just purchased the Ad Free version today. Thanks a lot for creating this Web App.
Shankar
Woow guys are u real !! 😂❤️ Free and quick support too 😁🔥 thnku so much guys , I'm sharing the Traders Casa in all groups and friends i know .. thank u so much 🙌🏽 much love and respect 🔥
SifouSifou
Guys Traders Casa is the best Backtesting platform on the web right now, not many people know about this, it's better than FX Replay. Very underrated. I just purchased the Ad Free version today...
@quasitrading
Been using this for over a months, it's really amazing software
@Abahrios
Thank you Traders Casa, without you my trading would not have improved. Thank you very much from Thailand. ❤️
@mAJOTRADER
🌟 I've been using @traders_casa for a few months now, and I have to say, their updates are insane! From new features to improved tools, they've really listened to our feedback and made meaningful changes.
@M4rky___
Man, if only I realised I could Backtest on mobile with @traders_casa 2 months ago🤩🤩.( I prefer trading on my phone).Backtesting is going to be the only game I play for a while🤣🤣already addicted
@Chihwa_fx
No way I have just found out about @traders_casa. You guys are absolute legends.
@Giorderflow
Yall deserve a 10 star if it was available
@Impulse__EU
For real yall should try out @traders_casa loving their free version and the paid version is even more amazing. The paid version gives you amazing analytics feature on your live account. It's superb. Mind you I have zero affiliation with these guys. I just live their work so much
@Impulse__EU
@traders_casa wowow! I just registered and in awe with your service!! Thank you so much 🥹
@Cubtradingfx
Having a statistical strategy with proof of it's max losing/winning streak probabilities will certainly build an effective risk management plan, set a reasonable expectations and even know if its seasonal or works for years. I got surprised @traders_casa provide free tool
@AkenyanTrader
How can I thank the creators and developers of traders casa personally?. They outdid themselves in creating this amazing project. I am forever grateful and thankful to them for making such available affordable options to millions of users. I can honestly say my trading improved a lot since I came across them. And it’s cost me way lesser than it would’ve on any other back testing sites. GRATITUDE 💪🏾
lollipop131513
Guys Traders Casa is the best Backtesting platform on the web right now, i honestly feel you guys have not done marketing well enough, not many people know about this, your platform is better than FX Replay. Very underrated. I just purchased the Ad Free version today. Thanks a lot for creating this Web App.
Shankar
Woow guys are u real !! 😂❤️ Free and quick support too 😁🔥 thnku so much guys , I'm sharing the Traders Casa in all groups and friends i know .. thank u so much 🙌🏽 much love and respect 🔥
SifouSifou
Edgewonk alternative FAQs
Is Traders Casa a good Edgewonk alternative?
Yes, particularly if you want chart-based backtesting as well as journalling. Edgewonk is primarily a journal and analytics platform with unusually strong psychology tools. Traders Casa lets you create new test trades by replaying historical charts bar by bar, then journal and analyse them. If detailed behavioural analysis and trading psychology are your main priorities, Edgewonk remains the more specialised choice.
Does Edgewonk have bar replay backtesting?
No. Edgewonk's strategy testing works with trades you have already taken, replaying those decisions under alternative management rules. It does not provide chart-based historical bar replay. Traders Casa lets you move through one-minute historical data bar by bar, place trades without seeing what comes next, rewind, jump to dates and review the resulting backtest afterwards.
Is Traders Casa cheaper than Edgewonk?
Traders Casa has a lower-cost entry point. Edgewonk costs $197 a year for its single plan, with VAT added at checkout depending on location, and has no free plan. Traders Casa is free forever for unlimited backtest sessions and trades. Basic costs $8.95/month or $7.16/month billed annually ($85.92 a year), while Pro costs $30/month or $24/month billed annually.
Which is better for trading psychology, Edgewonk or Traders Casa?
Edgewonk. Trading psychology is one of its clearest strengths: the Tiltmeter measures rule-breaking and connects discipline with P&L and win rate, alongside its Psychology Lab, mental journal and session report cards. Traders Casa focuses more broadly on testing, journalling and performance analysis. Choose Edgewonk for deeper behavioural analysis; choose Traders Casa when historical chart replay and backtest journalling matter more.
Test it yourself, free
The free plan is free forever — unlimited backtest sessions on TradingView-powered charts. If it's not for you, you've lost nothing.